Rentometer, Inc. | Data as of 10/22/2025
Bay Shore, a vibrant city on Long Island’s South Shore, offers a diverse rental landscape that appeals to young professionals, growing families, and retirees alike. Its charming waterfront setting, proximity to Sunken Meadow State Park, and easy access to the Long Island Rail Road make commuting to New York City straightforward while preserving a relaxed, coastal lifestyle. Residents enjoy a mix of historic homes, modern townhouses, and contemporary apartment communities, with popular neighborhoods such as Downtown Bay Shore, Willow Road, and the Bay Shore Village area providing convenient shopping, dining, and cultural attractions.
The local rental market reflects this variety, with studio apartments generally positioned in the $2200‑$2300 range, making them an attractive option for individuals seeking a low‑maintenance living space near the waterfront promenade and the historic Bay Shore Theatre. One‑bedroom units typically fall within the $2500 range, offering a comfortable balance of space and affordability for couples or remote workers. Larger families often gravitate toward two‑bedroom apartments, which are commonly listed in the $3000‑$3100 bracket, and spacious three‑bedroom rentals that command around $5000‑$5600, providing ample room for multi‑generational households or home‑based offices.
Beyond the apartments, Bay Shore’s modest inventory of single‑family homes adds a suburban feel for those desiring private yards and a more traditional living environment. The city’s blend of scenic beaches, vibrant downtown amenities, and well‑connected transportation options continues to draw renters seeking a high quality of life on Long Island, reinforcing Bay Shore’s reputation as a sought‑after rental destination.
| Property Type | Bedrooms | Average | Median | Min - Max | 25th - 75th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apartment | Studio | $2,276 | $2,250 | $1,840 - $2,775 | $2,085 - $2,520 |
| Apartment | 1 Bedroom | $2,495 | $2,495 | $900 - $3,831 | $2,350 - $2,850 |
| Apartment | 2 Bedroom | $3,072 | $3,025 | $1,040 - $4,509 | $2,860 - $3,375 |
| Apartment | 3 Bedroom | $5,502 | $4,979 | $3,550 - $7,977 | $3,550 - $7,977 |
In the current period, the average rent in Bay Shore was $2,277 for Studio, $2,497 for 1 Bedroom, $3,083 for 2 Bedroom, and $5,502 for 3 Bedroom.
Data provided by Rentometer, Inc.