Rentometer, Inc. | Data as of 10/22/2025
Mount Sinai offers a welcoming blend of suburban charm and convenient access to New York City, making it a highly desirable spot for renters seeking both tranquility and connectivity. The neighborhood is known for its tree‑lined streets, proximity to the beautiful Long Island Sound, and a variety of local amenities such as well‑rated schools, vibrant shopping districts, and easy access to the Port Jefferson Ferry. Outdoor enthusiasts appreciate the nearby Heckscher Park and the scenic hiking trails of the Hempstead Lake State Park, while commuters benefit from the efficient Long Island Rail Road service that delivers a swift ride into Manhattan.
The rental market in Mount Sinai is dominated by apartments, with two‑bedroom units being especially popular among families and professionals. These apartments typically fall within the $3800 range, reflecting the area's strong demand and high quality of life. Renters also enjoy a median price point around the $3500 range, which underscores the balanced affordability relative to the premium amenities and convenient location the community provides.
Residents take pride in the close‑knit community atmosphere, highlighted by frequent local events, farmers’ markets, and cultural festivals that celebrate the town’s rich heritage. With an array of dining options, boutique shops, and easy access to major highways, Mount Sinai stands out as a vibrant place to call home, offering a well‑rounded lifestyle for anyone looking to settle in a dynamic New York City suburb.
| Property Type | Bedrooms | Average | Median | Min - Max | 25th - 75th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apartment | 2 Bedroom | $3,822 | $3,395 | $2,395 - $5,200 | $3,295 - $4,975 |
In the current period, the average rent in Mount Sinai was
$3,822 for 2 Bedroom.
Note: This analysis includes only bedroom types with sufficient data.
Data provided by Rentometer, Inc.