1. Atlas Home
  2. New York
  3. Old Bethpage

Average Rent in Old Bethpage, NY
Apartments & Houses by Size

Rentometer, Inc. | Data as of 10/22/2025

Curious about how much rent goes for in Old Bethpage? Whether you're eyeing a studio apartment or managing a spacious 4-bedroom house, Rentometer has you covered with the latest average rent data across every property type and neighborhood.

This report covers average rent prices for apartments and single-family homes in Old Bethpage, broken down by bedroom count and neighborhood. All estimates are powered by Rentometer, the leading source for hyperlocal rental data and comps.

Limited Data: We only have 1 rental listing for this area. We need more listings to provide reliable statistics. Try nearby areas or check back later as we add more listings.

Old Bethpage

Rentometer subscribers can see individual property locations on the map in addition to the heatmap. Click here to Subscribe

Data provided by Rentometer, Inc.