Average Rent in Sheffield, OH
Apartments & Houses by Size

Rentometer, Inc. | Data as of 10/22/2025

Sheffield, Ohio, offers a welcoming blend of small‑city charm and easy access to the natural beauty of the surrounding Midwest. Situated along the banks of the Mahoning River, the city enjoys a vibrant downtown core, historic neighborhoods, and an array of parks and cultural venues such as the Sheffield Civic Center and the Riverfront Arts District. Residents appreciate the convenient proximity to major highways, local schools, and a growing selection of dining and retail options, making Sheffield an attractive place for professionals, families, and students alike.

The rental market in Sheffield is anchored by a solid selection of apartment communities, with two‑bedroom units representing a popular choice for those seeking spacious yet affordable living. Rental rates for these apartments typically fall within the $2100‑$2200 range, reflecting a competitive price point for the area’s amenities and location. Many complexes feature modern finishes, on‑site fitness centers, and easy access to public transportation, while newer developments in neighborhoods like the Riverfront District and the historic Oakwood Village area provide a blend of contemporary design and classic charm.

Overall, Sheffield’s rental landscape balances affordability with quality, offering renters a variety of housing options that suit diverse lifestyles. The city’s steady economic growth, coupled with ongoing investments in community infrastructure and local attractions, ensures that rental demand remains robust. Whether you’re drawn by the convenience of downtown living, the tranquility of nearby green spaces, or the close‑knit community feel, Sheffield’s rental market presents a compelling opportunity to call this Ohio city home.

Sheffield Rent by Property Type & Bedroom Count

Property Type Bedrooms Average Median Min - Max 25th - 75th
Apartment 2 Bedroom $2,161 $2,275 $1,600 - $2,550 $2,100 - $2,350

In the current period, the average rent in Sheffield was $2,161 for 2 Bedroom.

Sheffield

Rentometer subscribers can see individual property locations on the map in addition to the heatmap. Click here to Subscribe

Data provided by Rentometer, Inc.